Criminal Law Frequently Asked Questions. Charged with a Crime?
Frequently Asked Criminal Law Questions
If you’ve been charged with a crime, the United States Constitution and your state’s constitution promise you some very powerful protections.
With every step of the process, new rights will come into play.
A local criminal defense attorney will be able to look at your case in detail help make sure that your rights have been honored up to this point, and that you understand your rights going forward.
Your Rights Before the Arrest
You have the right not to incriminate yourself, which is commonly described as the right to remain silent. The right against self-incrimination is actually more complex than simply the right to remain silent.
You have the right to be free of unreasonable search and seizure, though there are various regulations and exceptions that accompany that right.
You have the right to an attorney.
Here at Total Lawyers, you will be able to get in touch with a criminal defense attorney.
You also have the right to be advised by police about these rights, commonly called Miranda Rights.
When can the police conduct a search of my property?
There are rules and regulations that surround police searches.
The police can search your home, property, car or financial records if they have probable cause to believe that they’ll find evidence of a crime, and therefore receive a search warrant issued by a judge.
But in some situations, the police can also conduct a search without a warrant.
If, for example, a potential piece of evidence is sitting out in the open, where there is “no reasonable expectation of privacy,” then the police aren’t required to have a search warrant to conduct a search.
They also don’t need a warrant if you voluntarily agree to a search.
Many people have let the police search when they didn’t have to, because they didn’t know they had the right to refuse.
It is easy to misstep and hurt your case, but a criminal defense attorney should be able to give you the explicit details of search and seizure laws as they pertain to your case.
When do the police have to read me my rights?
If you are a suspect, the police are required to read you your Miranda rights before conducting a custodial interrogation.
What exactly constitutes “custodial interrogation” has been the subject of many court cases, and is more complicated than you might expect.
Not all discussion between the police and a suspect is “interrogation.”
Some discussions are different than interrogation, like the kind of simple practical interaction that might occur between police and a suspect to ask if he wants something to drink, for example.
The police don’t need to read a suspect his or her rights at this point. However, in some circumstances a police officer may be found to have interrogated a suspect in custody even without asking direct questions.
Once a custodial interrogation begins, the police must read the suspects his or her rights and ensure that they are understood.
If the police don’t read my rights, are they forced to dismiss the charges?
Many people think that if the police don’t read them their rights, the charges are automatically dismissed.
This is usually not the case. (Read more Criminal Case FAQs here.)
Instead, if a suspect is interrogated in custody without being read his rights, then the statement he or she makes may be excluded as evidence.
Additionally, any evidence that wouldn’t have been discovered without that original statement may not be admissible as evidence either.
Sometimes this lack of usable evidence can lead to dismissed charges, but there is no automatic dismissal if a suspect’s rights are not read.
What does it mean when they say “you have the right to a speedy trial”?
The 6th Amendment guarantees that “in all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial, by an impartial jury…” But there isn’t a specific Constitutional guideline to determine what exactly constitutes a “speedy trial.”
Some jurisdictions have established set time periods within which a criminal case must pass through the system.
Cases that exceed these time periods-without good cause or delays at the request of the defendant-may be dismissed for that reason alone.
In jurisdictions without specific time limits, the courts typically consider the actual passage of time and reasons for the delay, how the delay may impact the case, and the defendant’s assertion of his rights to a speedy trial.
The seriousness of the charges and possible consequences can also impact the trial judge’s analysis, though this is not a consideration set forth by the Supreme Court.
When do I have the right to a trial by jury?
Any crime that may be punished by imprisonment for more than six months automatically triggers the right to a trial by jury, no matter what the offense is.
While there isn’t a universal definition of the term, those crimes determined to be “petty offenses” don’t necessarily warrant a trial by jury.
The number of people on the jury can vary also, depending on the state and the seriousness of your crime. Usually a jury of twelve must return a unanimous vote, though the U.S. Supreme Court has approved decisions by some states to accept verdicts that are not unanimous.
If the court uses a jury of 6, though, the verdict must be unanimous.
Recent U.S. Supreme Court decisions have also determined that if a defendant exercises his right to a trial by jury, aggravating factors for sentencing purposes must also be decided by a jury, and must be established beyond a reasonable doubt.
representative available 24/7 – Call 877-421-3761
The above summary of criminal rights is by no means all-inclusive and is not legal advice. For the latest information on criminal laws, speak to a local criminal defense lawyer in your state.